The NCIDQ IDPX exam tests the designer’s ability to manage discrepancies in construction documents and coordinate with other disciplines. A water closet’s placement not aligning with the contract documents is a significant issue that requires formal action to ensure consistency across all drawings.
Option A (Provide the dimensions of the water closet along with a notation on the interior design documents of the water closet’s new location):This option implies accepting the incorrect location and updating only the interior design documents, which does not resolve the discrepancy across all consultants’ drawings. It also does not involve the necessary parties to correct the error.
Option B (Coordinate the proper location with all parties through a change order):This is the correct choice. The designer should coordinate with all relevant parties (e.g., mechanical engineer, contractor, owner) to ensure the water closet’s location is corrected to match the contract documents. A change order is the formal process to modify the contract documents, ensuring all parties are aligned and the correction is documented.
Option C (Coordinate with the mechanical engineer and have the water closet relocated on the engineer’s drawings):While coordinating with the mechanical engineer is a step in the right direction, this option does not address the need for a formal change order or involve other parties (e.g., the owner, contractor). It is incomplete.
Option D (No action is necessary because the contractor is obliged to follow the interior design documents):This is incorrect. The contractor may follow the interior design documents, but if other consultants’ drawings (e.g., plumbing) are inconsistent, it can lead to errors during construction. The designer must proactively resolve the discrepancy to avoid issues.
Verified Answer from Official Source:
The correct answer is verified from NCIDQ’s official study materials on coordination and contract administration.
“When a discrepancy is found in consultants’ drawings, the designer should coordinate with all parties to resolve the issue and document the correction through a change order to ensure consistency across all contract documents.” (NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide, Coordination Section)
The NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide emphasizes the need to coordinate with all parties and use a change order to formally resolve discrepancies in contract documents. This ensures that all drawings are updated and aligned, making Option B the correct answer.
Objectives:
Understand the designer’s role in resolving drawing discrepancies (NCIDQ IDPX Objective: Coordination).
Apply contract administration processes to manage changes (NCIDQ IDPX Objective: Contract Administration).
[References:, NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide, Coordination Section., National Council for Interior Design Qualification (NCIDQ), IDPX Exam Blueprint, Section on Coordination., ]