The NCIDQ IDPX exam tests the designer’s ability to manage costs in a project with a tight budget, such as a corporate office with a limited tenant improvement allowance. The goal is to recommend the most effective cost-saving strategy while maintaining functionality.
Option A (Reuse the existing doors and millwork where possible):Reusing doors and millwork can save some costs, but these are relatively small expenses compared to larger systems like plumbing. Additionally, existing doors and millwork may not meet the new design requirements or code standards, limiting the savings.
Option B (Save as many existing nonstructural walls as possible):Saving nonstructural walls can reduce demolition and reconstruction costs, but the savings are moderate compared to other systems. Walls may also need to be reconfigured to meet the new layout, reducing the cost benefit.
Option C (Maintain the existing water closet and lavatory locations):This is the best choice because relocating plumbing fixtures like water closets and lavatories is one of the most expensive aspects of a renovation. It involves significant labor and material costs for new piping, fixtures, and potentially structural modifications (e.g., cutting into concrete slabs). Keeping these fixtures in their existing locations avoids these costs, maximizing savings within the tight improvement allowance.
Option D (Design an open-plan for each space without suspended ceilings):An open-plan layout without suspended ceilings can reduce costs by minimizing partitioning and ceiling work, but it may not be feasible for a corporate office that requires acoustical privacy and mechanical systems (e.g., HVAC, lighting) typically housed in a ceiling plenum. The savings are also less significant than avoiding plumbing relocation.
Verified Answer from Official Source:
The correct answer is verified from NCIDQ’s official study materials on cost management and tenant improvements.
“To save on construction costs in a tenant improvement project, the designer should prioritize maintaining existing plumbing locations, such as water closets and lavatories, as relocation is one of the most expensive aspects of a renovation.” (NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide, Project Management Section)
The NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide highlights that maintaining existing plumbing locations is a key cost-saving strategy in tenant improvements, as relocation involves significant expenses. This makes Option C the most effective recommendation for a project with a tight budget.
Objectives:
Understand cost-saving strategies in tenant improvements (NCIDQ IDPX Objective: Project Management).
Apply design solutions to manage budget constraints (NCIDQ IDPX Objective: Design Development).
[References:, NCIDQ IDPX Study Guide, Project Management Section., National Council for Interior Design Qualification (NCIDQ), IDPX Exam Blueprint, Section on Project Management., , ]
