Full Access CFA Institute ESG-Investing Tutorials

There is a high correlation between country ESG risk and credit ratings. Countries with higher ESG risks typically face higher borrowing costs and lower credit ratings due to the perceived increased risk associated with environmental, social, and governance factors. This correlation reflects the importance of ESG factors in assessing the overall creditworthiness and financial stability of countries​​​​.

Dynamic materiality refers to the concept that what is considered financially material for a company can change over time, necessitating continuous review by investors. Here’s a detailed explanation:

Materiality in ESG: Materiality in ESG context refers to the relevance and importance of certain environmental, social, and governance factors in affecting a company’s financial performance.

Dynamic Materiality: This concept recognizes that the significance of specific ESG factors can evolve due to changes in regulations, market conditions, societal expectations, and other external influences. Therefore, what might not be material today could become material in the future.

Continuous Review: Investors must constantly monitor and reassess ESG factors to ensure that their understanding of what is financially material remains current. This ongoing process helps investors to make informed decisions that reflect the latest material risks and opportunities.

Contrast with Static Materiality: Unlike static materiality, where material factors are considered fixed and unchanging, dynamic materiality acknowledges the fluid nature of ESG factors. This requires a more proactive and adaptive approach to ESG analysis and integration.

CFA ESG Investing References:

The CFA Institute explains that “dynamic materiality acknowledges the evolving nature of ESG issues and the need for investors to continually reassess what is material” (CFA Institute, 2020).

Dynamic materiality is highlighted as a key concept in modern ESG investing, emphasizing the importance of ongoing review and adjustment in investment strategies to account for changing material factors​​​​.

By understanding and applying the concept of dynamic materiality, investors can better navigate the complexities of ESG investing and align their portfolios with the most relevant and impactful factors over time.

=================

Screening on a relative basis would most appropriately be used to construct a balanced and diversified portfolio. This approach involves comparing companies within the same industry or sector and selecting those that perform better on ESG criteria relative to their peers.

Relative Comparison: Screening on a relative basis allows investors to identify the best-performing companies within each sector or industry, ensuring a balanced approach across different segments of the market.

Diversification: By selecting top ESG performers from various industries, investors can maintain a diversified portfolio while still adhering to ESG principles. This helps in spreading risk across different sectors.

Sector-Neutral: This approach ensures that the portfolio is not overly concentrated in specific sectors, which can happen with thematic investing or absolute screening. It allows for sector-neutrality, maintaining exposure to a broad range of industries.

References:

MSCI ESG Ratings Methodology (2022) - Discusses the benefits of relative ESG screening for constructing diversified portfolios​​.

ESG-Ratings-Methodology-Exec-Summary (2022) - Highlights the importance of maintaining diversification while applying ESG criteria in portfolio construction​​.

Under the disclosure guide for public equities published by the Pension and Lifetime Savings Association (PLSA), fund managers are expected to report on both ESG integration and stewardship activities. Here's a detailed explanation:

ESG Integration:

Fund managers are required to disclose how they integrate ESG factors into their investment processes. This includes the identification and management of ESG risks and opportunities.

They need to provide examples of material ESG factors identified in their analysis, how these factors influence their investment decisions, and how they monitor ESG risks over time .

Stewardship Activities:

Stewardship activities involve how fund managers engage with companies they invest in to promote sustainable business practices and good governance.

This includes voting at shareholder meetings, engaging in dialogue with company management, and participating in collaborative initiatives aimed at improving ESG standards across the industry .

CFA ESG Investing References:

The CFA Institute’s ESG curriculum emphasizes the dual role of ESG integration and stewardship in sustainable investing. Both aspects are crucial for ensuring that ESG considerations are fully embedded in the investment process and that fund managers actively contribute to improving corporate practices through engagement and voting .