CIMA F3 Exam With Confidence Using Practice Dumps

When valuing an unlisted company using a P/E ratio from a similar listed company, we normally reduce the proxy P/E to reflect the extra risk and reduced attractiveness of the unlisted investment.

A. Relative lack of marketability – Unlisted shares are harder to sell and usually take longer to realise, so investors demand a higher return, i.e. a lower P/E. ✔

B. Lower level of scrutiny and regulation – Unlisted companies face less disclosure and governance requirements, so information risk is higher. Greater risk ⇒ lower valuation multiple ⇒ reduced P/E. ✔

C. Smaller and less established – Unlisted companies tend to be smaller, less diversified and less stable, so investors again expect a higher return, implying a lower P/E. ✔

D. Control premium not included – If the proxy P/E excludes a control premium but you are valuing a controlling stake, you would increase the P/E, not reduce it. ✘

E. Higher forecast earnings growth – Higher expected growth justifies a higher P/E, not a lower one. ✘

F. One-off profit item in latest earnings – This should be dealt with by adjusting the earnings, not by cutting the P/E multiple. ✘

So the three factors justifying a reduction in the proxy P/E are A, B and C.

Given current structure: D:E = 25:75, tax = 25%, asset beta ≈ 1.01.

Re-gear beta for new structure D:E = 35:65

βe′=βa[1+(1−T)DE]=1.01[1+0.75×3565]≈1.01×1.404≈1.42\beta_e' = \beta_a \big[1 + (1 - T)\frac{D}{E}\big] = 1.01 \big[1 + 0.75 \times \frac{35}{65}\big] \approx 1.01 \times 1.404 \approx 1.42βe′​=βa​[1+(1−T)ED​]=1.01[1+0.75×6535​]≈1.01×1.404≈1.42

Use CAPM with rf=4%r_f = 4\%rf​=4%, rm=12%r_m = 12\%rm​=12%:

ke′=rf+βe′(rm−rf)=4%+1.42×8%≈4%+11.4%≈15.4%k_e' = r_f + \beta_e'(r_m - r_f) = 4\% + 1.42 \times 8\% \approx 4\% + 11.4\% \approx 15.4\%ke′​=rf​+βe′​(rm​−rf​)=4%+1.42×8%≈4%+11.4%≈15.4%

Closest option: 15.36% → B.

A. The issue of bonds might limit the availability of debt finance in the future.

If the project is financed by a bond, gearing rises to 2:5, increasing financial risk and using up debt capacity. A rights issue instead reduces gearing to 1:5, preserving future borrowing capacity.

C. The rights issue will lead to less pressure on the operating cash flows of the programme.

Bond finance requires fixed interest payments (and eventual redemption), which must be met regardless of project cash flow variability. Equity raised via a rights issue has no mandatory interest and dividends are discretionary, so it places less strain on operating cash flows.

So the answer is:

Answer: A and C