CIA IIA-CIA-Part2 Reddit Questions

An The top-down approach to understanding business processes is conducted from a broad organizational perspective, beginning with the overall objectives and strategic goals of the organization and then drilling down into the specific processes that support these goals. While this approach ensures alignment with the organization's objectives, it has the greatest risk of overlooking critical processes at the lower levels, especially those that might be operationally significant but not directly linked to top-level objectives.

IIA References:

IIA Standard 2010: Planning suggests that internal auditors should understand the organization’s business processes in relation to its objectives. The top-down approach aligns with this but can risk missing important operational details that might be captured through a more granular (e.g., bottom-up) approach.

The data extracted by the internal auditor includes human resources data with employment conditions, payroll data, and entrance logs. With this information, the auditor can identify employees who are getting paid even though their employment has expired. By comparing the employment conditions and expiration dates in the HR data with the payroll data, the auditor can detect discrepancies where individuals continue to receive payments beyond their employment period. Entrance logs can help corroborate these findings by showing the lack of physical presence of these employees, further supporting the identification of ghost employees who no longer work for the organization but still appear on the payroll.

References:

IIA Practice Guide: "Auditing Employee Benefits"

COSO Internal Control – Integrated Framework

Stratified sampling is used when the population can be divided into distinct subgroups (strata) that differ significantly from each other but are internally homogeneous. In the context of auditing, revenue earned through cash receipts or as receivables would have different characteristics and risk profiles. Stratifying the population allows the auditor to ensure that each subgroup is adequately represented in the sample, leading to more reliable and accurate audit conclusions.

References:

The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) Practice Guide: Audit Sampling

IIA Standard 2320 - Analysis and Evaluation

Proper engagement supervision is documented through formal records that show a systematic review and oversight process. A completed engagement workpaper review checklist provides evidence that the supervisor has reviewed and approved the work done by the audit team. This formal checklist ensures all critical aspects of the engagement are reviewed systematically, meeting the standards for proper supervision documentation. References:

"Internal Auditing: Assurance & Advisory Services" (The Institute of Internal Auditors)

"International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing" (IIA)