CGFM Exam Questions Tutorials

Role of the Independent Auditor in Financial Reporting:

Independent auditors evaluate internal controls as part of their audit procedures to support an opinion on the fair presentation of the financial statements. This includes assessing whether internal controls over financial reporting are designed and operating effectively.

This evaluation helps ensure that financial statements are free of material misstatements, whether due to error or fraud.

Why Management Does Not Do This:

Managementdesigns and implements internal controls but does not evaluate them to support the auditor’s opinion. Management’s responsibility is to certify the accuracy of the financial statements, while the auditor provides an independent opinion.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

C. The program office:This entity oversees operations but does not perform evaluations to support an audit opinion.

D. The audit committee:The committee provides oversight of the audit process but does not perform the evaluation itself.

References and Documents:

GAAS (Generally Accepted Auditing Standards):Outlines the responsibilities of independent auditors regarding internal control evaluation.

GAO Yellow Book:Specifies the role of external auditors in evaluating internal controls during financial audits.

Definition of Cost-Effectiveness Measures:

Cost-effectiveness measures assess therelationship between inputs (resources used)andoutcomes (results achieved)to determine whether a program delivers value for the resources invested.

Explanation of Answer Choices:

A. Efficiency measures: Incorrect. These relate inputs to outputs, focusing on how efficiently resources are used to produce services, but not directly tied to outcomes.

B. Process measures: Incorrect. These measure activities or steps within a program but do not assess outcomes.

C. Cost-effectiveness measures: Correct. These directly link inputs to outcomes, measuring the program’s effectiveness in achieving its objectives relative to costs.

D. Activity measures: Incorrect. These track the level of activity or effort but not outcomes or effectiveness.

References:

GASB,Performance Measurement and Reporting for Government Programs.

GAO,Best Practices in Measuring Program Effectiveness.

How to Prioritize Controls Based on Cost and Risk:

The priority of a control is based on its cost-effectiveness. Controls that protect assets with higher risk exposure relative to the cost of the control should be prioritized. The formula to calculate cost-effectiveness is: Cost-Effectiveness=Cost of ControlAsset Amount at Risk\text{Cost-Effectiveness} = \frac{\text{Cost of Control}}{\text{Asset Amount at Risk}}Cost-Effectiveness=Asset Amount at RiskCost of Control​

Lower ratios indicate more cost-effective controls.

Calculations:

Asset A:$15,000 / $150,000 = 0.10 (10%)

Asset B:$2,500 / $6,000 = 0.42 (42%)

Asset C:$50,000 / $2,000,000 = 0.025 (2.5%)

Asset D:$20,000 / $500,000 = 0.04 (4%)

Lowest Priority:

Asset Bhas the highest ratio (42%), meaning it is the least cost-effective and should be the lowest priority for controls.

References and Documents:

COSO Internal Control Framework:Discusses cost-benefit analysis for prioritizing controls.

GAO Risk Management Guide:Emphasizes evaluating control cost-effectiveness relative to asset risk.

Why Is This the Best Measure for Performance?

Comparing thecost per acre maintainedto that of another jurisdiction provides a meaningful benchmark for performance evaluation. It allows the director to assess how efficiently the department is operating relative to similar organizations.

This comparison ensures that the department is managing resources effectively and identifies potential areas for improvement.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. Use a single measure of citizen satisfaction:While citizen satisfaction is important, it is subjective and does not provide insight into operational efficiency.

B. Evaluate funds spent on grounds maintenance:Total spending does not measure efficiency or productivity; it merely reflects the amount allocated.

C. Analyze staffing levels:Staffing levels do not directly measure performance; they are only one factor in determining efficiency.

References and Documents:

Governmental Performance Reporting (AGA):Recommends using comparative benchmarks for evaluating efficiency in service delivery.

Performance Management Framework by GAO:Highlights cost-effectiveness metrics such as cost per acre maintained.